2006 Mequoda Media Website Design Award Winners

For the past 12 months, the Mequoda Research Team has been methodically discussing, reviewing and rating media websites. Each website is nominated by one of seven Mequoda Website Reviewers (Robert W. Bly, Terri Edmonston, Larry Kerstein, Kim Mateus, Roxanne O’Connell, Roger C. Parker, and Peter A. Schaible), who make the case that the website is very good (or very bad) at demonstrating one or more of the 14 Mequoda Website Design Guidelines. At least one other member of the reviewing team must second the nomination, then the detailed 14 step website design and usability review process begins, culminating with a peer review and publication in the Website Design for Publishers & Authors volume of the Mequoda Library.

  • Fourteen of the 48 websites earned a Grade “A” website design and usability rating on the Mequoda Website Design Scorecard with a total score of 3.50 or better on the 4.0 scale.
  • Atkins.com and Better Homes & Gardens (BHG.com) tied for the highest score, each earning a 3.86 Grade “A” Rating on the Mequoda Scorecard.
  • The media websites under review includes both B2C and B2B websites and encompassed all seven of the Mequoda Website Archetypes.

In 2004, the Mequoda Research Team reviewed hundreds of media websites to identify what we now call the seven Mequoda Website Archetypes and to create a standard expert scale for measuring website design and usability—codified as the Mequoda Website Design Scorecard.

Find out the CMS features that publishers require to manage an online publishing business. Download a FREE copy of 7 Ways Haven Wordpress Goes Beyond Wordpress, and discover the features all publishers should have access to for a bigger audience, greater revenue, and higher profits.

Media Website Design—The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

During 2005, our intrepid research team put the Mequoda Website Design Scorecard to work by using it to perform expert reviews of 48 media websites. With a high score of 3.86 (a tie between Atkins.com and Better Homes & Gardens (BHG.com) and a low score of 1.57, the scoring system validated its ability to help expert reviewers parse good website design from bad. The scorecard and the 48 expert reviews offer those who design websites for media organizations of all sizes an integrated set of concepts and cases to build better websites that will create happier users and healthier profits.

Mequoda Group
2006 Media Website Design Awards
48 Media Websites Compared on 14 Website Design Guidelines
Website Design Review Score Grade Reviewer URL
Atkins.com 3.86 A O’Connell Site
Better Homes & Gardens 3.86 A O’Connell Site
WebMD 3.71 A Edmonston Site
Morningstar.com 3.71 A Edmonston Site
Credit Today 3.71 A Schaible Site
The Daily Reckoning 3.71 A Schaible Site
Fit Forever with Denise Austin 3.64 A Bly Site
Baby Center 3.64 A Edmonston Site
Firehouse 3.64 A Parker Site
The Accounts Payable Network 3.57 A Schaible Site
Motor Trend 3.57 A Schaible Site
America’s Test Kitchen 3.50 A Kerstein Site
Lending Tree 3.50 A O’Connell Site
eBay 3.50 A Schaible Site
The Motley Fool 3.43 B Kerstein Site
Wine Spectator Online 3.43 B Mateus Site
The Book Standard 3.43 B Schaible Site
WSJ.com 3.36 B Edmonston Site
Bottom Line Secrets 3.36 B Schaible Site
Roll Call 3.29 B Kerstein Site
AdAge.com 3.29 B Schaible Site
Book Reporter 3.21 B Parker Site
Blue Nile 3.20 B Bly Site
eDiets 3.14 B Bly Site
BlueDolphin.com 3.14 B Mateus Site
Element K Journals 3.10 B Kerstein Site
Monster 3.07 B Clausen Site
BLR.com 3.07 B Mateus Site
AutoTrader.com 3.07 B Parker Site
UsedBoats.com 3.07 B Parker Site
Computerworld 3.00 B Edmonston Site
Lawyers.com 3.00 B Kerstein Site
Rich Dad, Poor Dad 3.00 B Parker Site
Entrepreneur.com 2.93 B Parker Site
Moneylaundering.com 2.93 B Schaible Site
iFly.com 2.86 B Mateus Site
Means Business 2.71 B Edmonston Site
Briefings Publishing Group 2.64 B Parker Site
Fundcraft 2.50 B Edmonston Site
Insurance.com 2.50 B Schaible Site
Executive Travel Sky Guide 2.43 C Edmonston Site
SalaryExpert.com 2.43 C Edmonston Site
Texas Monthly 2.43 C Schaible Site
Personnel Policy Service 2.07 C Schaible Site
Hcpro 1.86 C O’Connell Site
CEO Perspectives 1.64 C Parker Site
Ragan Communications 1.57 C Parker Site

To create the 14 Mequoda Website Design Guidelines, we’ve reviewed hundreds of media websites and interviewed dozens of website authors, publishers and designers. We’ve conducted expert usability reviews and actual user tests to determine what we believe to be the top 14 website design best practices for the seven Mequoda Website Archetypes.

While these 14 guidelines are by no means the complete list of website design practices, they are essential to sound, effective website design. We’re sure that implementation of these practices will result in happier, more satisfied, users.

  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #1: Strategic Intent
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #2: Content Webification
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #3: Relationship Building
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #4: Community Building
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #5: Persistent Navigation
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #6: Task Depth
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #7: Affordance
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #8: Labeling and Language
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #9: Readability and Content Density
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #10: Content Organization
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #11: Content Freshness
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #12: Load Time
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #13: Aesthetics
  • Mequoda Website Design Guideline #14: Brand Preference

Leave a Reply