Evaluating Risks and Embracing Change: How the Forward-Looking Management of Mother Earth News is Transforming a Traditional Print Magazine Publisher Into a Cutting-Edge, Online Information Provider
If your magazine and the brand it represents have survived and grown for 35 years, you might be tempted to rest on your laurels. “If it ain’t broke…” But smart publishers recognize that both the market and the medium are constantly evolving. The Internet forever changed the way thinking people consume information. It also presented new challenges and opportunities to savvy publishers and marketers.
Ogden Publications, based in Topeka, Kansas, publishes more than a dozen magazines and books for people interested in self-sufficiency, sustainability, rural lifestyles and farm memorabilia. Its flagship is Mother Earth News, where much of the content is devoted to “doing more with less, creating great communities, living wisely and all facets of the joyful good life!” With the creation of a network of websites and a bold vision for the future of its publishing enterprise, Ogden has embarked on a new direction for the Mother Earth brand that will redefine “creating great communities.”
- Since its fledgling start, the Mother Earth News website has added books and construction plans, organic coffee and tea, coffee mugs and assorted collectibles to its product mix
- Next, the publisher added Google AdSense to the Mother Earth News website. “We just basically turned this Google thing on and every month it gets about 40 percent larger,” said Bryan Welch, publisher
- Then, the company decided it needed to optimize its website for the search engines, so it invested $5,000 in training from a search engine optimization (SEO) specialist. The results were dramatic
- At this point, the management of Mother Earth News began to think of themselves as not just magazine publishers, but as online information providers
- “This is the Internet. Is all that money wasted and all that time wasted a huge tragedy, with great mountains of unsold magazines plowed into a landfill somewhere? No, we change it and move forward”
Mother Earth News is a bimonthly magazine dedicated to presenting information that helps its readers become more self-sufficient, financially independent and environmentally aware. Readership age ranges from the early teens to 90-plus, with a mix of brand-new readers and others who have been subscribers for decades. The magazine has a paid circulation of approximately 350,000 and is read by nearly a million people across the United States and Canada.
Since 1970, Mother Earth News has been an exemplary source of information about sustainable homesteading, rural skills, environmental consciousness, real food and natural health. It is North America’s leading publication for people interested in contemporary rural lifestyles.
Interest in these topics is increasing as Americans enter the second half of the decade and the oldest Baby Boomers approach retirement age. Many are searching for this information online.
In response, the management of Mother Earth News is developing new information products and expanding its reach on the Internet. According to Bryan Welch, publisher and general manager of Ogden Publications, the evolution of the magazine’s online efforts started in earnest in 1997 as they began to digitize and archive previously published content.
This is his story, as he related it to an audience of publishing executives at Mequoda Summit.
When Ogden acquired Mother Earth News, it took possession of nearly 30 years of previously published articles. In its first online marketing effort, the company repackaged the content on compact discs (CDs), bundling 10 years of back issues on each CD. It also added all the archived stories to its website.
“We talked about not putting the content online because we were going to try to sell CDs, but not having any idea how this business worked— not having any idea what we were doing—we decided to do both and see what happened,” said Welch. “The CDs sold like hotcakes, and traffic on the website went way up, so we decided to keep doing both. And so far, it’s a good business plan.”
Since its fledgling start, the Mother Earth News website has added books and construction plans, organic coffee and tea, coffee mugs and assorted collectibles to its product mix. Under consideration are photographs, prints and posters, as well as video clips and 130 audio recordings of old Mother Earth News radio programs that ran on public radio stations in the 1970s.
Next, the publisher added Google AdSense to the Mother Earth News website.
“We just basically turned this Google thing on and every month it gets about 40 percent larger,” said Welch.
Then, the company decided it needed to optimize its website for the search engines, so it invested $5,000 in training from a search engine optimization (SEO) specialist. The results were dramatic.
According to Welch, monthly website page views grew from 600,000 in 2004 to 1.5 million in 2005. Other highlights:
- Daily visitors to the site jumped from an average of 8,000 in 2004 to an average of 33,000 in 2005.
- Monthly subscription sales went from $8,000 in 2004 to $30,000 in 2005.
- Average monthly product sales were $7,500 in 2004 vs. $16,000 for 2005.
- Total online revenues for August 2004 were $16,300 vs. $53,000 for August 2005.
- Google ads brought the company a monthly average of $800 in 2004; they’re averaging $7,000 a month for 2005.
Editor’s note: The passive income from Google AdSense is an online publisher’s dream. See Google AdSense: Easy Money for Web Publishers.
“You all know what sort of expenses you have to put against that $7,000 a month don’t you? Nothing. Zero. Nada. That’s $7,000 that traveled rapidly and directly to the bottom line,” Welch said.
|Mother Earth News||2004||2005|
|Average monthly page views||600,000||1,500,000|
|Average daily visitors||8,000||33,000|
|Average monthly subscription sales||$8,000||$33,000|
|Average monthly product sales||$7,500||$16,000|
|Average monthly Google AdSense revenue||$800||$7,000|
|Month of August online revenue||$16,300||$53,000|
A New Business Model is Preceded By a Shift in Thinking
At this point, the management of Mother Earth News began to think of themselves as not just magazine publishers, but as online information providers.
“What we’ve done is, not taken our business into the Internet,” Welch explained. “In essence, we launched a new business that’s Internet-based, utilizing a set of resources that we already had at hand.
“It was very, very hard for us to visualize this. We kept thinking that all of our love and dedication and affection were invested in magazine publishing, and in the magazines we published. And a lot of the decisions we made about how these websites looked, how they worked, how we interacted with them, required that we put distance between ourselves and our old ways of defining our identity and our product.”
At first, the changes were particularly difficult for some Mother Earth News editors, but now they are generally supportive, Welch said.
“They’re much more concerned about the relationship with the readers and the importance of the content,” he explained. “What we’ve accomplished, more than growth in the size of the revenue strength, is growth in the size of the audience. And that’s very cool for editors.”
The Mother Earth Wiki is Born
“The most controversial thing that we’ve done in terms of the editors, and really the hardest thing for us to get our minds around, is we’ve taken all this content and loaded it into the Wiki environment, which gives us an interactive encyclopedia.
“Here comes the tricky part,” Welch said. “It’s interactive. We are going to put it out on the Internet and let people interact with it, modify it and change it. So from another perspective, this is by far the hardest piece of information to swallow.”
The Mother Earth Library will be a separate website that includes 35 years of content from the Mother Earth News magazine. With the power of the Internet and cutting-edge Wiki software, the Library will bring together a community of conscientious citizens. Anyone can participate in expanding and updating the entries on wise living.
Site visitors are invited to be volunteer editors and update the articles. Anyone who registers for the site can use the Mother Earth Library to learn about sustainable living topics by perusing thousands of articles or by asking questions of the experts on its discussion pages. Site users who have personal experience or knowledge about sustainable living can add their own information to enrich the many entries, or enter new wise living topics.
“As editors, we spend our whole careers filtering, refining, focusing and processing the content, and now we’re going to put our content on the Internet and let everybody in the world change this work,” Welch said. “This could be really ugly. It also could be really amazing. It also could be really beautiful.”
A New Interactive Medium and the Risks of Change
Bryan Welch is a thoughtful publisher with extraordinary business acumen. He has carefully considered the changes his company is making, and he knows they are not without risk. He is both philosophical and practical.
“We had to do it because this really is a new medium,” Welch explained. “This really is a new paradigm for whatever you want to call the business we’re in. The community building, is it publishing? Is it advertising? Audience development? Whatever you want to call it, this is brand new, this is interactive.
“What happens after you go on the Internet and you really have this huge palette to paint on? And you can scramble it in all these ways, interactively, and let other people chime in and interact with you and change your product?
“What happens to that brand, that Mother Earth News brand? Well, it concerned us. What we’ve done, for the time being, is we’ve created an umbrella brand that is bigger than Mother Earth News and called it Mother Earth Living. We’re launching the Mother Earth Living network, which is basically an additive branding move instead of a deductive branding move.”
When built out, the Mother Earth websites will comprise a Mequoda Website Network that includes:
- Mother Earth News—The original guide to living wisely.
- Mother Earth Living—Tips, expert advice and email reminders for wiser living.
- Mother Earth Forums—The meeting place for people interested in sustainable living topics.
- Mother Earth Shopping—Books and more great green stuff!
- Mother Earth Coffee and Tea—Organic coffee and tea for sale.
- Mother Earth Library (Coming Soon)—More than 7,000 entries maintained by a volunteer community of users.
Final Thoughts… for now
“What if we’re wrong?” Welch asked philosophically.
“This is the Internet. Is all that money wasted and all that time wasted a huge tragedy, with great mountains of unsold magazines plowed into a landfill somewhere? No, we change it and move forward.”